Market Commentary for 10/24/14
I noticed big changes along I-80 and I-35 during my drive back to MN from the farm this week. Nearly all of the beans had been harvested, with most combines picking corn. I didn’t see any elevators with piles of corn, but in most areas farmers are behind with their harvest.
Fundamentally the trade is bearish, but farmers have built a lot of storage in the past few years. So, many can “sit tight” on their harvest during drops in the market. End users, on the other hand, may have to work harder to get farmers to sell. It is uncertain if this will lead to upside potential in the future. There are so many questions:
Beans continue to surprise the grain trade. Fundamentally beans should be bearish, but this isn’t the case. Where will the bean market go now? There are several factors at work:
Perhaps prices will have trouble continuing to rally. Following are uncertainties that could affect future prices:
Corn has also had nice runs recently, but it seems these have been more supported by beans. Fundamentally there is a 2 billion bushel carryout that will need to be addressed at some point in the future. That amount is nearly double the carryout of the ‘13/’14 marketing year.
On Friday, November options expired. The CBOT recorded the largest options position in history against the November. I’ve mentioned several of my trades in the past with with November options. Following provides where my options expired and the results to my position.
The three options above were used to reduce my risk for the 2015 crop. I mentioned two weeks ago, I had already “rolled” these anticipated futures positions to the July ’15 futures contract at a $.32 premium. I plan to roll them to the Nov ’15 contract later in the year.
On 2/19/14 I sold Nov bean futures for $11.44 and bought a $12 call for $.44, because I wanted down-side protection and up-side potential. Then on 6/20/14 I sold the $12 call back for $.75 and bought a $13.00 call for $.30, because I expected beans had reached a near-term peak with the recent rally. I wanted to take some of the profit. I still had the protections in place to the down-side, but I would get $.45 more. If there was a drought, I still had up-side potential that started at $13. Obviously there was no drought issues and the market fell. The $13 call expired worthless and I netted $11.45 on those beans.
On 8/29/14 I sold a $3.60 Nov corn option (Nov corn options are based on the Dec futures price as of close on Friday) for $.125 that expired today. As corn is below $3.60 I have not sold any corn with this trade and I get to keep the $.125. I’m happy with the premium and will look to try and repeat this type of trade down the road.
On 10/9/14 I sold a $3.40 Nov corn option for $.115 that expired today. As corn is above $3.40 I have now sold corn for $3.40 Dec futures but I get to keep the $.115 premium which means it’s like selling $3.515. With the market closing right at that value and with negative bias to the corn board over the next month I feel ok selling corn at this level. If I add the profits from the corn call above to this trade I actually trade a price higher still of $3.64.
The point in sharing this is to not only provide transparency in my positions, but to illustrate how using options reduces farmers risk while providing up-side opportunity. Also, describing my positions in more detail hopefully reduces the fear of more complicated grain marketing strategies. Farmers don’t need to be fearful of this type of marketing.
More Market News…